My favorite character in the HP series. That's because we have a lot in common. Especially spacing out. :D
Same rule applies.
Book-movie difference HP5
· At Wisteria Walk; Harry was supposed to point a wand at Dudley on the alleyway not at the park.
· At the Dursley House; the letter from the ministry was not supposed to be a semi-howler. It was just a letter.
· At the Dursley House; Kingsley was not supposed to be the one who told Harry about the Hearing. It was supposedly through the letter from the ministry.
· At Grimmauld Place; how Moody opened the house was wrong. Harry was supposed to read the address of the house of a slip of paper and memorize it so the house could materialize before his eyes. *It defeats the purpose of the secret-keeper charm. Χ
· At Grimmauld Place; the argument between Molly and Sirius was supposed to be at the kitchen, not at the meeting room. *It’s better that way, using extendable ears and doing the argument. Hitting two birds with one stone.
· At the Ministry of Magic; there’s nowhere in the book about an elevator boy. As the elevators go on their own. Χ
· At the Ministry of Magic; Harry and Mr. Weasley was supposed to be late for 10mins, not 5mins early.
· At the Ministry of Magic; Harry and Mr. Weasley was supposed to see Lucius Malfoy talking to the Minister after the hearing, not before.
· At Kingscross Station; it was supposedly Moody who gave Harry the picture of the whole order of the phoenix, not Sirius. It was at Grimmauld Place too.
· At Hogwarts Express; Hermione and Ron was supposed to be patrolling the train corridors as they were prefects, not just sitting there with Harry. *Come to think of it, them being prefects was not mentioned in the movie at all! Χ
· At Hogsmeade Station; the carriage was supposed to have a roof or is enclosed, not open just in case of rain. Χ
· The hole behind the Fat Lady portrait was supposed to be circular, not arched. *But arched is better. It’s hard to climb into a circular door. √
· In Umbridge’s first class; students from four houses were in one room. It supposed to be just two houses in one class. *Because each house and year level are supposed to be blocked or in one room together with another house on the same year level. Χ
· At Hogwarts; education decrees were supposed to be posted in the bulletin, not nailed. *How do they expect students to read those nailed announcements when it was too far up?? Χ
· At the Forbidden Forest; the one who said about “if it’s just you alone, you’re not as much of a threat..” was supposed to be Remus at Grimmauld place, not Luna. *But it made Luna’s airtime longer. I like that. J √
· At the Forbidden Forest; there’s also nothing in the book about Harry and Luna feeding the Thestrals.
· At the Hog’s Head; it was supposed to be Susan Bones who asked if Harry can produce a patronus, not Luna.
· It was not Neville who found the Room of Requirement. It was Dobby who told Harry about that said room. *They tend to cut off Dobby’s part. So sad.
· At the Room of Requirement; Hermione was supposed to say to Harry, “We’re just gonna be in the library…” not, “We’re gonna be in the common room…” before Christmas holidays. *Makes more sense. √
· Cho’s mother is not in the ministry as opposed to what Hermione had said. She’s not worrying about O.W.L.S. either as she’s already finished with it because she’s a year ahead. Χ
· At the Department of Mysteries; Arthur Weasley was supposed to be guarding the door to it and not inside it.
· The occlumency lesson was supposed to start after Christmas Holidays, not right after Harry saw Mr. Weasley’s attack. *I know it’s for shorter airtime. But Harry was still so clammy after the dream. And how do they expect him to close his mind? He needed rest, not mind exhaustion. Χ
· At Grimmauld Place; the Black family tree was not supposed to have pictures, just names. *But it made the masses realize the connection between Bellatrix and Sirius. √
· At Hagrid’s hut; Umbridge was supposed to come by after Harry, Ron, and Hermione had come in and it’s supposed to be night time. *It would take time as they will need the invisibility cloak.
· At Hagrid’s hut; he spoke like he went to find the giants alone when he was supposed to be with Madame Maxime.
· At the Room of Requirement; Neville was not supposed to tell Harry about the plight of his parents because they found it out at St. Mungos. *They tend to cut the part of St. Mungos too. I’ve always wanted to see how they represented that wizarding hospital. Tsk2. Χ
· At the Room of Requirement; there was nothing in the book about Umbridge bombarding the room. They were supposed to escape except for Harry. *I’m not sure they will be able to bombard it even. The room was supposed to not be there for people who don’t need it exactly as the people inside it anyway. So silly. Χ
· Cho was not the one who sold the D.A. members but Marietta her friend. Χ
· At Dumbledore’s office; it was supposedly Professor McGonagall who was holding Harry and Cho, not Percy.
· At Dumbledore’s office; it was supposedly Phineas Nigelllus who said, “Dumbledore’s got style…” not Kingsley.
· During the flight of Fred and George; Harry was not supposed to have the vision that time but during dozing off the O.W.L.S. exam room.
· Hagrid was supposed to ask Harry and Hermione during the Quidditch match, not at a corridor. Ron was not supposed to be with them too as he was supposedly playing in the match. *They didn’t emphasize the Quidditch match at all. So bad. L Χ
· At the Department of Mysteries; the prophecy was not supposed to say the prophecy when held by the person whom the prophecy was made. It did not do so in the book. *So how are they gonna be able to hear the prophecy then? √
· At the Department of Mysteries; Harry was supposed to be the one who broke the prophecy, not Lucius.
· At the Ministry of Magic; Dumbledore was supposed to arrive before Voldemort did.
· At the Ministry of Magic; Cornelius Fudge was supposed to arrive in his pajamas.
No comments:
Post a Comment